The General Plan

Contract

Treasury Publishes FY27 SIPPRA Notice of Funding Opportunity with Rigorous Evaluation Requirements

The Treasury Department has released its FY27 Social Impact Partnerships To Pay for Results Act funding opportunity, setting detailed evaluation design and independent evaluator standards that applicants must meet.

The Treasury Department has published its FY27 Notice of Funding Opportunity under the Social Impact Partnerships To Pay for Results Act (SIPPRA), establishing detailed application requirements centered on rigorous outcome evaluation design and the qualifications of independent evaluators.

Evaluation Design Plan Requirements

A core application component is the evaluation design plan summary, which must be limited to 3 pages or fewer. The summary must demonstrate that the proposed evaluation will be designed to determine whether outcomes were achieved as a result of the intervention — not merely that outcomes occurred. The notice requires applicants to address six specific topics within this summary.

First, applicants must identify outcome metrics and data sources, specifying for each metric the data source, data owner, expected outcome target or payment threshold, and why the metric is an independent, objective indicator of impact not subject to manipulation by the service provider, intermediary, investors, or other project partners. Second, applicants must describe the evaluation design and comparison group, identifying the proposed methodology — such as a randomized controlled trial, regression discontinuity design, difference-in-differences design, matched comparison design, or another rigorous methodology — and explain how the design will support causal conclusions.

Third, applicants must address randomization feasibility: if random assignment is feasible, they must briefly describe how it would occur; if not feasible, they must explain why and identify the strongest feasible alternative. Fourth, a preliminary power calculation must be provided for each primary outcome or payment metric, identifying expected treatment and control or comparison group sizes, the expected effect the intervention is designed to achieve, and whether the proposed sample is large enough to detect that effect, along with the main assumptions affecting the calculation such as attrition, missing data, take-up, clustering, or repeated observations.

Fifth, applicants must address data access — identifying the data needed to conduct the evaluation and stating the status of access to each major data source, including whether data-use agreements, memoranda of understanding, consent forms, or other approvals are in place or will be needed. Where federal administrative data are required, the notice specifies that applicants must identify the federal data source, expected access pathway, and any known gaps or risks. Sixth, applicants must identify the main risks to the evaluation's ability to produce credible causal estimates — such as insufficient sample size, missing data, attrition, weak service contrast, contamination, changes in policy or service availability, implementation challenges, or inability to access required data — and briefly describe how the applicant and independent evaluator expect to mitigate them.

The notice explicitly states that at the application stage, applicants are not required to provide final regression equations, final covariate specifications, minimum detectable impact estimates, final hypothesis testing procedures, or a full implementation evaluation protocol. However, if selected for an award, the awardee must submit a full Evaluation Design Plan after award, in the form and timeline required by Treasury.

Independent Evaluator Standards

The notice sets parallel requirements for evaluator qualifications, also capped at 3 pages or fewer. Applicants must address the evaluator's independence from all other entities involved in the project, as well as experience conducting rigorous evaluations including well-implemented randomized controlled trials and quasi-experimental analyses on the intervention or similar interventions, covering both personnel and organizational experience. Specific qualifications required include: experience working with the datasets the project expects to use; prior work in conducting implementation and causal impact evaluation; qualifications of key personnel designing and overseeing the evaluation, including education or training and type and years of experience; experience managing similar evaluation protocols; and experience dealing with unforeseen data or implementation issues in other program evaluations, with specific examples required.

Applicants must also provide a copy of the contract or agreement to be entered into between the state or local government and the independent evaluator. That contract must address the plan to obtain relevant datasets from local, state, or federal agencies; design and coding of a management information system tailored for research or evaluation; collection or assessment of individual-level data with appropriate data-use agreements that assure data quality and adherence to federal and state data privacy statutes and applicable data security standards; Institutional Review Board approval or a plan to obtain it; submission of progress reports to Treasury, the Interagency Council, and the head of the relevant agency; and a payment plan detailing the annual payment schedule. The notice states that the selection of an independent evaluator is subject to the procurement requirements of the Uniform Guidance, including those related to competitive procurement.

What to watch

The notice does not specify a deadline in the available record. Awardees should note the post-award requirement to submit a full Evaluation Design Plan in the form and timeline required by Treasury.

What this means for recipients

State and local governments applying under the FY27 SIPPRA notice must prepare a 3-page-or-fewer evaluation design plan summary addressing all six specified topics and a separate 3-page-or-fewer independent evaluator qualifications summary, and must submit a copy of the evaluator contract or agreement as part of the application. If selected for award, the awardee must submit a full Evaluation Design Plan after award per Treasury's required form and timeline. The independent evaluator selection process is subject to the Uniform Guidance's competitive procurement requirements, and all data arrangements must comply with applicable federal and state data privacy statutes and data security standards.

Related

Sources

21 cited

Every hard fact above is grounded in and cited to a primary source record.

  1. The Treasury Department published the FY27 Social Impact Partnerships To Pay for Results Act Notice of Funding Opportunity.

    federalregister.gov
  2. The evaluation design plan summary must be limited to 3 pages or fewer.

    federalregister.gov
  3. The summary must demonstrate that the proposed evaluation will be designed to determine whether the outcomes were achieved as a result of the intervention.

    federalregister.gov
  4. Proposed evaluation designs may include a randomized controlled trial, regression discontinuity design, difference-in-differences design, matched comparison design, or another rigorous methodology.

    federalregister.gov
  5. If random assignment is feasible, applicants must briefly describe how it would occur; if not feasible, they must explain why and identify the strongest feasible alternative evaluation method.

    federalregister.gov
  6. A preliminary power calculation must be provided for each primary outcome or payment metric, identifying expected treatment and control or comparison group sizes and the expected effect the intervention is designed to achieve.

    federalregister.gov
  7. Main assumptions affecting the power calculation include attrition, missing data, take-up, clustering, or repeated observations.

    federalregister.gov
  8. Where federal administrative data are required, applicants must identify the federal data source, expected access pathway, and any known gaps or risks.

    federalregister.gov
  9. Main evaluation risks identified in the notice include insufficient sample size, missing data, attrition, weak service contrast, contamination, changes in policy or service availability, implementation challenges, or inability to access required data.

    federalregister.gov
  10. At the application stage, applicants are not required to provide final regression equations, final covariate specifications, minimum detectable impact estimates, final hypothesis testing procedures, or a full implementation evaluation protocol.

    federalregister.gov
  11. If selected for an award, the awardee must submit a full Evaluation Design Plan after award, in the form and timeline required by Treasury.

    federalregister.gov
  12. The independent evaluator qualifications summary must be limited to 3 pages or fewer.

    federalregister.gov
  13. Applicants must address the evaluator's independence from all other entities involved in the project and the evaluator's experience conducting rigorous evaluations including well-implemented RCTs and quasi-experimental analyses.

    federalregister.gov
  14. Evaluator qualifications must cover both personnel and organization experience.

    federalregister.gov
  15. Applicants must provide a copy of the contract or agreement to be entered into between the state or local government and the independent evaluator.

    federalregister.gov
  16. The evaluator contract must address Institutional Review Board approval or a plan to obtain it to ensure the protection of human subjects, to the extent applicable.

    federalregister.gov
  17. The evaluator contract must address submission of progress reports to Treasury, the Interagency Council, and the head of the relevant agency.

    federalregister.gov
  18. The evaluator contract must include a payment plan that details the annual payment schedule.

    federalregister.gov
  19. The selection of an independent evaluator is subject to the procurement requirements of the Uniform Guidance, including those related to competitive procurement.

    federalregister.gov
  20. Data-use agreements must assure data quality and adherence to all federal and state data privacy statutes and policies and to all applicable data security standards.

    federalregister.gov
  21. For each outcome metric, applicants must identify the data source, data owner, expected outcome target or payment threshold, and why the metric is an independent, objective indicator of impact not subject to manipulation by the service provider, intermediary, investors, or other project partners.

    federalregister.gov